pointslip milestomorrow.com

American Express Cash Magnet Card vs The Platinum Card

Both are American Express cards. Here is every spend category, ranked by what each card actually returns.

Best card by category Card terms as of Oct 29

Everything else

  1. The Platinum Card 2.0% 1x base rate
  2. Cash Magnet Card 1.5% 1.5% base rate

Flights

  1. The Platinum Card 10.0% 5x, capped
  2. Cash Magnet Card 1.5% 1.5% base rate

Flights · portal

  1. The Platinum Card · American Express Travel 10.0% 5x

Hotels · portal

  1. The Platinum Card · American Express Travel 10.0% 5x

What the numbers are doing

The Platinum Card's 5x on flights runs out: it applies to the first $500,000 of flights spend a year, and everything past that earns 1x.

The Platinum Card tops everything else at 2.0% only because this table values its points at 2 cents each. Value them at one cent and Cash Magnet Card wins that category instead.

The table is earn rate only — annual fees are not netted out of it. These cards charge Cash Magnet Card $0 and The Platinum Card $895 a year, so a thin lead in one category may not cover the difference.

pointslipEveryday
Pass content preview
CategoryBest card
Everything elseThe Platinum Card2.0%
FlightsThe Platinum Card10.0%
Flights · portalThe Platinum Card · American Express Travel10.0%
Hotels · portalThe Platinum Card · American Express Travel10.0%

Content preview. Apple Wallet controls the layout; visible categories vary by device. Categories that rank the same as Everything else are left off; every other category is in pass details.

Every category, every card

Everything else

  1. The Platinum Card — 2.0%
  2. Cash Magnet Card — 1.5%

Flights

  1. The Platinum Card — 10.0%
  2. Cash Magnet Card — 1.5%

Flights · portal

  1. The Platinum Card · American Express Travel — 10.0%

Hotels · portal

  1. The Platinum Card · American Express Travel — 10.0%
Add to Apple Wallet

This link hands the pass straight to Wallet, no app and no account — its first three rows; the app unlocks every row.

iPhone app · not yet released

Preview this set of cards. The first three rows are free, whatever cards you hold; every row and every feature is $9.99 once, in the app. See the free combos.

Open this ranking in the generator

A cheat sheet in your Wallet that tells you which card to use. No account, no bank linking, no subscription.